Lorenz Lehmann: wider ohne rede
für Sopran und Saxofon
(2026)In the chapter ‘The End of Communicative Action’ in his book *Infocracy*, Byung-Chul Han describes the crisis of democracy as a crisis of listening: ‘Discourse requires us to separate our own opinion from our own identity. People who lack this discursive ability cling desperately to their opinions, because otherwise their identity is threatened. For this reason, any attempt to dissuade them from their convictions is doomed to failure. They do not listen to others; they do not really listen. Yet discourse is a practice of listening. The crisis of democracy is, first and foremost, a crisis of listening.”
This reflection prompted me to explore what remains of one’s own identity when we listen to another person with genuine openness and set aside our own opinions for a moment in order to adopt a different point of view.
What does not dissolve in this shift in perspective is, for me, an invisible resistance. It need not be articulated, but can also persist in the act of listening. It is a silent rebuttal–a ‘rebuttal’ without speech.
In the piece, we encounter the two performers, Alessia Park (soprano) and Nikola Lutz (saxophone), in three different ways: on stage, they interact musically without speaking. Through the loudspeakers, we hear their recorded material in a heavily distorted form. Finally, in the video, they appear both as listeners and as speakers. There, they comment on their own act of listening, their resistance to what they hear, and the resulting uncertainty about their identity.
(Lorenz Lehmann)